Top 10 Best Glass Fireplace Doors of 2021 – Reviews

Finding decent glass fireplace doors shouldn’t be too difficult nowadays, not if you take the time to learn as much as you can about what constitutes a decent fireplace door, to begin with. Along with the construction, one needs to consider both the sturdiness and the visibility such a door provides, hopefully finding the ideal balance between the two.

Not just that but considering how inexpensive some of them are, it would be a shame to simply go for the cheapest model you can find when even the good ones are quite affordable. To give you a better idea of what’s out there, we put together a list of the ten best glass fireplace doors the market has to offer right now, but before we get into fireplace door screens and glass door options, we thought that it would be beneficial to go through why someone might have to replace glass in fireplace door and other important information regarding that process.

Why Replace Glass in Fireplace Door?

Over time, the doors especially if they’re glass, for fireplaces can be distorted due to the heat. They tend to get darker by the heat and really takes away from the glow of the fire. Although it’s more of a cosmetic reason to replace glass in the fireplace door, there are a lot of practical reasons why you should do it as well.

Glass doors on your fireplace are there for safety reasons. Without glass doors on your fireplace, there’s a greater chance that someone, like a small child, could get hurt. Regardless if you have children or not, pets are also known to get a little curious about fires and get too close as well. To avoid anyone, including yourself getting burned by hot embers, installing a glass door, or ensuring that your existing glass door is up to standard is essential and will really make the fireplace experience a lot more enjoyable and a lot less stressful.

Another aspect that you may not know about glass doors is that they actually help your fire burn better. So you’re not only protecting yourself, your friends, and your family with a glass door, but you’re also protecting the fire from blowing out. Glass doors enclose the burning area which allows the firewood to burn greater and produce a lot more heat. The glass doors also absorb and radiate any heat into the room much better than a fireplace without any doors at all and especially without glass doors.

How to Replace Fireplace Glass Door

Replacing your glass door in your fireplace shouldn’t be too difficult. In fact, most products make it extremely easy and straightforward. Some general tips when it comes to replacing the glass in your fireplace door include the following:

1. Start with having your fireplace cool for 2 hours or more. The doors of the fireplace should be cool to the touch
2. Make sure to wear gloves and open both doors. Reach behind the upper corner of the door where you should find pivots at the lintel or at the upper portion of the frame. Find the thumbscrew and loosen it by hand. You can also do this with pliers if it’s too difficult to do by hand.
3. Hold the door together with one hand, slide the upper edge of the door inside towards the middle of the lintel until the doors are clear and slowly lift them up and out of the framework.
4. Repeat this same process on the other side.
5. Close one of the new sets of hinged doors together when they’re closed you will see the handle or knob of the innermost door facing out. You should angle the set of the doors to fit the pivot-pin at the lower edge of the outdoor door into the hole at the lower end of the frame.
6. Move the upper edge of the set towards the side open. Align the edge of the outer door in line with the framework and reach up behind the outer door and tighten the thumbscrew until it’s tight.
7. Repeat on all doors.
8. Close the doors and ensure that the seams meet in the middle of the lintel. When correctly tighten the seam should be about 1/8 inch wide when the doors are fully closed.

For more ideas of how to install your particular doors, you should always check the instructions included in your glass door fireplace kit.

Now that you’ve learned more information on why it’s important to replace glass in fireplace doors and have fireplace door screens or a glass fireplace door replacement in your fireplace, it’s time to start looking at the best of the best when it comes to just that! Scroll down below to see the best glass fireplace door options on the market today.

Best Glass Fireplace Doors, Reviews

#10 Fireplace Glass Doors for Superior-Lennox Fireplace

The Fireplace Glass Doors for Superior-Lennox Fireplace by Pathline products is a door that delivers both high-performance and reliability. Engineered to minimize the loss of heat during winter, this glass door fits most fireplace models including BC36, BR36, HC36, RD36, BBV36, and BCF36.

Available in 3 different stylish finishes including black, silver and polished brass, these doors are easy to install and maintain. Made from high-quality materials, the center is crafted from nylon resin while the ends are cast with a durable e-coat finish.

#9 Heatilator Fireplace Doors

The Heatilator Fireplace Doors are heavy-duty, 42-inch glass doors that are designed for maximum reduction of heat loss. Made from tough high-grade materials, the doors come equipped with clear tempered glass that offers full visibility of the fireplace.

Available in two stunning finishes including black and stainless steel, these doors would enhance the overall outlook and class of your fireplace efficiently. Easy to install and set up, the doors are only suitable for E/EC/EL/HR/HC 42-inch Heatilator fireplaces.

#8 Pathline Products 36″ Fireplace Glass Door Set

Made from high-grade materials, the Pathline Products 36″ Fireplace Glass Door Set is durable, reliable and designed to accentuate the outlook of your fireplace. Suitable for all Heatilator or Heat & Glo fireplaces, this glass door set is engineered to reduce the amount of heat loss in winter and save on air conditioning during summer months.

Equipped with thick, tough glass, it offers clear visibility of the fireplace and protects your family from dangerous sparks. Easy to install, these doors take approximately 10 minutes to set up and are easy to maintain and clean.

#7 Pleasant Hearth EN-5501 Pleasant Hearth Enfield Glass Firescreen

Known for its performance, durability and elegant outlook, the Pleasant Hearth EN-5501 Pleasant Hearth Enfield Glass Firescreen features a robust construction that is designed to minimize the loss of cool or hot air when the fireplace is not in use.

Crafted with a high-temperature burnished bronze finish with smoked glass, this firescreen would accentuate any living room décor with ease. Suitable for masonry fireplace openings that measure approximately 30 to 37 inches wide and 25.5 to 32.5 inches high, this glass door comes with thick heat resistant insulation, along with hidden damper control knobs for controlling air-flow.

#6 Pleasant Hearth EA-5011 Easton Black Firescreen Medium Fireplace Glass Door

Crafted to fit openings measuring approximately 30 to 37 inches high and 25.5 to 32.5 inches wide, the Pleasant Hearth EA-5011 Easton Black Firescreen Medium Fireplace Glass Door features a high-quality gunmetal finish that would accentuate any living room décor.

Made from premium materials, the doors include a fine mesh panel with tough smoked glass that offers optimum heat retention for up to 90% when the fireplace is not in use. Including 5 inch sturdy handles on each door, the doors come with damper control knobs for optimum airflow and a thick heat resistant insulation. Each door features 9 cabinet prairie style panes that are elegant and classy.

#5 Pleasant Hearth CB-3300 Colby Fireplace Glass Door

Another premium fireplace door from Pleasant Hearth is the CB-3300 Colby Fireplace Glass Door. Measuring approximately 30 to 37 inches wide and 22.5 to 27.5 inches high, these doors feature a stunning cabinet-style design. Made from tough gauge steel with a beveled frame measuring 1 3/4th inch, these doors come with a sunlight Nickel finish with durable smoked glass.

Engineered to reduce heat loss for up to 90% when the fireplace is not in use, these doors also prevent the loss of cool air-conditioning during summer months. Adding a touch of style with high performance, these doors are only suitable with masonry fireplaces and not pre-fabricated ones.

#4 Large Beveled Glass Diamond Fireplace Screen

Featuring a set of 4 glass panes with floral tempered glass inserts, the Large Beveled Glass Diamond Fireplace Screen is designed with alternating panels that are extremely stylish and elegant. Made from tubular steel with a strong mesh, this 2 door fireplace screen includes robust hinges and a magnetic latch along with sturdy handles for optimum safety.

Crafted with a flat-guard design, the screen comes with feet on the front and back and fits flush against the fireplace for added protection against dangerous sparks. Durable, lightweight and classy, this glass fireplace door is designed to match any home décor.

#3 Plow & Hearth Small Steel Crest Fireplace Screen with Doors

Crafted with an exquisite scrollwork design made from wrought iron, the Plow & Hearth Small Steel Crest Fireplace Screen offers an elevated style and elegance to your fireplace. Designed with a 2-door opening, each door includes a magnetic latch and strong hinges for secure closure.

The doors feature an arched design and are equipped with sturdy handles that offer a good grip. Made from high-quality materials, including tubular steel and mesh, the doors are lightweight and durable and come with a powder-coated finish.

#2 Pleasant Hearth AN-1010 Alpine Fireplace Glass Door

The Pleasant Hearth AN-1010 Alpine Fireplace Glass Door is a small, sleek and classy tempered glass door that is designed to provide you with clear visibility of your fireplace. Measuring approximately 30-37 inches wide, this door comes with a 180-degree firebox opening and a black finish.

Crafted from high-grade tough materials, the door is held together by robust gauge steel with a 1-inch frame. Thanks to the 2 grid mesh panels with magnets that sit behind the glass door, it offers optimum protection from sparks. Easy to set up, these doors take just an hour to install and are easy to clean.

#1 Pleasant Hearth FN-5701 Fenwick Fireplace Glass Door

Featuring a versatile design and construction, the Pleasant Hearth FN-5701 Fenwick Fireplace Glass Doors comes with a prairie cabinet style that is stylish and modern. Equipped with a safety tempered smoked glass measuring 3/16th inch, the doors include tough mesh panels and strong high-grade hinges with heavy-duty magnets.

Quick and easy to install, these doors do not take time to set up and come along with a 2-inch riser bar. Crafted from high-quality materials, the door features an oil-rubbed bronze finish and reduces heat loss for up to 90% when the fireplace is not in use.

Overall Thoughts

We hope that you found this post helpful when it comes to finding the perfect fireplace door screens or glass fireplace door replacement for your existing fireplace. Fireplaces have some many great benefits, but you want to ensure that it’s safe especially if you have kids or pets running around. Ensuring that you have a high-quality fireplace door screens or glass fireplace door replacement in place will help provide you with the peace of mind that you and your little ones are always safe around the fire. 

We hope that this post not only gave you important insight into things you should consider when searching for your perfect fireplace door screens regardless if it’s a replace glass in fireplace door option or glass fireplace door replacement, but there are also so many options on the market today, that if you go with any of the top-rated options above, we’re sure you’ll be thrilled with the experience.